April 20, 2007
Cotton Seed Distributors
article
Today I am talking to Dr Mike Bange from the Australian Cotton
Research Institute and we are going to talk a little bit about
earliness and managing the crops for maturity.
So Mike you and some of your
colleagues have done quite a bit of work on this over a number
of years, could you explain a little bit about some of the
experiments and trials that you have done to look at the concept
of earliness?
Yes Rob, a few years back Grant Roberts and Steve Milroy and
myself ran a series of trials at all different scales to look at
the concept of maturity and earliness. We had a number of large
scale field trials in a number of different regions looking at
principally the impact of IPM and different varieties, the IPM
elements being comparing INGARD® at that time versus
conventional varieties. We had some detailed agronomy trials run
here at the research station where we looked at full
combinations of nitrogen, by water, by PIX, by varieties looking
at how those different management regimes were impacting on
maturity and we have run some detailed physiology trials where
we are looking at different varieties with different maturity
and trying to understand how those varieties mature and why they
mature differently. So we have had a fairly complete look at
earliness and maturity.
Can we go into a little bit more of the detail; could you
outline what the components of earliness are that are driving
early maturity ?
We pretty well broke it down into a series of factors affecting
maturity or earliness. The major ones we saw as we had to look
at were obviously the season length where you grew the crop, the
next most important one was variety followed by and appropriate
IPM strategy and modifying your IPM strategies to impact on
fruit retention was the issue in terms of driving maturity then
followed by some more minor things and we were quite
surprisingly things like nitrogen, water and PIX were the other
elements that contributed to earliness, but much less than
variety and IPM.
So looking at correlations I guess there has always been a
thought that there are negative correlations between yield and
earliness, is that what you found?
Unfortunately with earliness there is a price to be paid. You
have got less time to grow a crop and less time to produce
yield. On average over five seasons we have found for up to .6
or around ˝ a bale per hectare of lint yield was lost for every
weak reduction in maturity – it can be quite significant.
And what management factors can influence earliness so if you
had to produce an early crop what are some of the things you
would do to do achieve earliness in a relatively short season
area?
Probably the things that I would like to quote is some figures
in terms of what management factors actually did in terms of
their impact on earliness and these are averaged over four or
five seasons. For variety obviously they can have big impacts
and that varies for the regions and that short of thing. IPM, we
could modifying fruit retention we could bring the crop forward
by up to 10 to 20 days so that is quite a big impact. For
nitrogen we could move the crop for up to 2 to 3 days and about
a similar amount for PIX. Knocking off the last irrigation had
little or essentially no impact, the fruit had been set and it
was going to mature anyway but it did impact on yield, the bolls
were smaller. - so there basically the scale of the affects of
those different management regimes.
And what about spray on earliness such as PIX, there is a lot
of anecdotal evidence that PIX will have a major impact on
earliness?
Well it is important probably to make the distinction about how
you use PIX so if you are using PIX to assist with vegetative
growth there is no benefit in using PIX to bring the crop early.
If you are using PIX for “cut out” rates of PIX it will have an
impact, you are basically shutting the crop down but some of the
work that Grant did he was spraying high rates of PIX at
flowering and he found that in the end though he was only
bringing the crop forward by 2 to 3 days but there are certainly
lots of things to suggest that if you hit it with high rates of
PIX and continually hit it with high rates of PIX it will shut
the crop down. For some people that is an obvious management
strategy if they want to finish a crop by a certain time.
I guess manipulating earliness in short season areas is
important to reduce the chance of weather damage we are all
aware of those concepts and they make sense, but just to bring
it a little bit more relevant to the current year, quite a few
areas are limited with water they are going to run out of water
early, are early crops always more water use efficient?
Well essentially yes, they are not growing for as long so they
are going to use less water but at the same time they are going
to produce less yield. In terms of lint yield, we are not so
much talking about water use efficiency as in terms of amount of
lint per water applied, what we are talking about is just less
water use, I can’t say that early crops are actually more water
use efficient as in water applied per bale of cotton lint. So
definitely shorter crops will use less water and that is an
obvious management strategy to deal with in limited water years.
Is there any more ongoing research on earliness? Have you
given up on it or is there still more work to be done?
Maturity obviously is an important element in terms of crops
because if we change the maturity we are impacting on yield.
Some of the things that we are investigating and still working
with is we have got Rose Roche’s work on narrow row and
different populations and looking at how those systems can
impact on earliness and whether there is any relationship and
one of the things that we are looking at is how the
relationships of plant populations and row spacing interact with
other management factors and potentially changing maturity. Some
of the other work that we have followed on from the work that
Grant, Steve and myself did is we looked at some of the issues
relating to the physiology of crop determinacy so trying to
understand the concept of crop determinacy. Then there is the
work that Steve Yeates and Dirk Richards are doing with Bollgard
high fruit retention cotton and obviously looking at the systems
maturity is an important aspect that they are doing. So we
certainly haven’t ignored it we are just looking at it in
different ways.
Thanks very much for that Mike. |
|