Davis, California
April 20, 2007
Pharmaceutical crops -- those
genetically engineered to produce medicines, vaccines and other
pharmaceutical proteins -- have been cultivated on a limited
scale in California amid increasing U.S. Department of
Agriculture regulations to reduce risk of gene flow and
contamination of human food and livestock feed, according to a
review article published in the April-June 2007 issue of the
University of California's peer-reviewed California Agriculture
journal. See the entire current issue of California Agriculture
at
http://californiaagriculture.ucop.edu.
In an eight-page article, Michelle Marvier, associate professor
of biology and environmental studies at Santa Clara University,
explores the complex scientific, environmental and public policy
issues surrounding pharmaceutical crops, and sets forth three
frameworks for assessing their risks and benefits.
"Like many new technologies, the genetic engineering of crops to
produce pharmaceutical products has great promise. Bananas that
could cheaply and easily deliver vaccines throughout the tropics
could be a wonderful invention," Marvier wrote. "But there are
downsides; it will be difficult to avoid food contamination and
potential harmful effects to wildlife if pharmaceuticals are
widely produced in food crops grown out of doors."
Eighteen federal permits were issued between 1996 and March 2007
for field trials in California involving pharmaceutical or
industrial proteins. Some of these approved permits were for
field trials of Ventria Bioscience's rice, engineered to express
human genes with medicinal properties. These field trials were
opposed by rice growers concerned about the possible
contamination of rice destined for export, and Ventria has since
moved its production of pharmaceutical rice out of California.
Also in the current issue, University of California researchers
report on the emergence of glyphosate (Roundup)-resistant
horseweed in noncrop areas of California. While the authors did
not determine the source of horseweed resistance in these areas,
there have been numerous reports of Roundup-resistant weeds
occurring near row crops such as corn and soybeans that have
been genetically engineered to be resistant to the herbicide
glyphosate.
These two articles continue a California Agriculture series on
the risks and benefits of agricultural biotechnology, which
began with peer-reviewed articles on gene flow, and transgenic
animals and fish in the July-September 2006 issue:
http://californiaagriculture.ucop.edu/0603JAS/toc.html.
Read the entire current issue of California Agriculture:
http://californiaagriculture.ucop.edu
California Agriculture is the University of California's
peer-reviewed journal of research in agricultural, human and
natural resources. |
|