California
October 17, 2006
Before the year's end, a team of
scientists will begin collecting data for a long-planned
four-year study on the sources of E. coli O157:H7 in the Salinas
Valley. The study is funded with a $1.2 million research grant
from the USDA.
"Exactly where the E. coli is coming from is a focus of the
grant," said Edward (Rob) Atwill, a UC Davis School of
Veterinary Medicine specialist in waterborne infectious diseases
and co-principal investigator of the study. "There has been much
speculation that livestock or wildlife are possible sources of
the E. coli O157:H7 in these outbreaks in fresh produce from
Salinas Valley region. We will examine livestock and wildlife
that are out on the rangeland up above the farmland, and
wildlife that live near canals and on the periphery of vegetable
fields on the valley floor."
In the first two years of the study, crews will collect
thousands of samples of domestic animal and wildlife droppings;
creek, ditch and irrigation water; farm soil and lettuce growing
on Salinas Valley farms. (This study was designed before the
late summer 2006 outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 associated with
spinach. Several previous outbreaks of the virulent bacteria
were associated with contaminated Salinas Valley lettuce.)
The data collected in the field will be carefully analyzed to
identify the vertebrates that are sources of E. coli O157:H7,
assess the climate, landscape attributes and irrigation
management practices that are correlated with increased risk of
contamination, and determine whether contaminated lettuce is
associated with certain farming practices or environmental
factors.
"We need to deal with facts," said Robert Mandrell, research
leader of the USDA-Agricultural Research Service Produce Safety
and Microbiology Research Unit and the principle investigator of
the study. "Right now, we can't say what's happening. We will
get facts that will give us a basis to determine what more we
need to investigate."
Facts will come also from the use of sophisticated tests called
MultiLocus Variable tandem repeat Analysis (MLVA) and Pulsed
Field Gel Electrophoresis (PFGE) to "fingerprint" and track
bacteria found in various animals, waterways, farms and
vegetables. PFGE is the same process used by the Centers for
Disease Control to discover whether food-borne disease outbreaks
are related to one another, as was found to be the case with
spinach in September 2006, and MLVA is a recent method for
assessing the relatedness of strains isolated.
"Most strains of E. coli O157:H7 bacteria are so similar, we
need to look at the genome to accurately trace the source
through the environment," Mandrell said.
The scientists hope their research will also help them
understand the puzzling timing of recent E. coli outbreaks. E.
coli bacteria are found more often in Salinas Valley waterways
in the winter, when rainstorms can wash the bacteria from
streets, farms, and rangeland into creeks, streams, sloughs and
rivers. However, the outbreaks associated with fresh vegetables
tend to happen during the summer and fall.
"Is there a hydrological link between what is occurring on
rangeland above the fields and the E. coli contaminated
vegetables that are reported in the summer and fall? That's what
we are going to test," Atwill said.
Certain strains of E. coli bacteria normally live in the
intestines of cattle, wildlife and humans causing no harm. The
O157:H7 strain became known in 1982 as a result of an outbreak
associated with hamburger meat. It causes severe diarrhea and
can lead to kidney damage and even death. Young children and the
elderly are particularly vulnerable. However, some humans with
E. coli O157:H7 show no symptoms at all.
"There's a lot we don't know about why certain people don't get
sick," Mandrell said. "Are certain strains more virulent? The
particular strain in the spinach outbreak seems to be
particularly virulent."
Compared to other strains of E. coli, the O157:H7 strain is
unusually persistent in the environment. It survives in low
temperatures, such as cold water and under refrigeration. Heat,
in the pasteurization of milk and fruit juices or in cooking,
destroys E. coli bacteria. E. coli on the outer surfaces of cuts
of meat are easily destroyed during cooking. But E. coli in
ground meat may be deep within the hamburger. Cooked hamburgers
with pink meat in the middle can still have live E. coli
O157:H7 cells.
Cooking vegetables also destroys bacteria, but contaminated
vegetables meant to be eaten raw pose the problem. Washing
rarely completely cleans all the bacteria off and very little
bacteria can make a person ill. It is thought that only 10 to
100 bacteria can cause disease in humans; a large animal with E.
coli O157:H7, such as a cow, sometimes can shed millions of
bacteria per gram of feces.
The information from Mandrell, Atwill and their colleagues' E.
coli study will be used to inform growers about specific
strategies they can use to prevent contamination of vegetables
in the field, to educate the public about the potential impacts
of rangeland runoff, and to develop effective management
practices for improving water quality.
The scientists involved in the study are Mandrell; Atwill;
Michael Cooley, microbiologist, USDA-ARS-WRRC-PSMRU; Ken Tate,
UC Cooperative Extension rangeland watershed specialist, UC
Davis Department of Plant Sciences; Royce Larsen, UC Cooperative
Extension area natural resource watershed advisor, San Luis
Obispo County; Leta Crawford-Miksza, Chief, Food Microbiology
Section, Food and Drug Laboratory Branch, California
Department of Health Services; Janet Mohle-Boetani, Chief,
Disease Investigations Section, Infectious Diseases Branch,
California Department of Health Services; and Michelle
Jay-Russell, Western Institute for Food Safety and Security, UC
Davis and California Department of Health Services. |