Greensboro, North Carolina
December 19, 2003
Syngenta Crop
Protection Inc. today filed a civil suit in Federal District
Court in Delaware against
Sipcam Agro USA Inc. of Roswell, Ga., in response to false
and misleading claims by Sipcam about its Stalwart(tm)C and
Stalwart(tm)Xtra herbicides, containing the active ingredient
metolachlor.
Syngenta believes that Sipcam is misleading growers in its
advertising, which claims that Sipcam's metolachlor herbicides
deliver the same weed control as Syngenta's new S-metolachlor
herbicides Dual II MAGNUM® and Bicep II MAGNUM®.
S-metolachlor is the active isomer of metolachlor. Syngenta
developed S-metolachlor to provide growers with effective weed
control at 65 percent of
the rate of old metolachlor. EPA registered S-metolachlor in
1997 as a reduced-risk herbicide. Since Syngenta's introduction
of S-metolachlor, approximately 20 million fewer pounds of
active ingredient are applied each year - a substantial
reduction in environmental exposure.
Sipcam's brands, with old metolachlor as the active ingredient,
were registered by EPA in 2002 and 2003, at 65
percent of the rates approved for the old metolachlor
sold by Syngenta for more than 20 years. Sipcam's current
advertising campaign claims equivalent weed control performance
with their metolachlor products compared to Syngenta's improved
S-metolachlor. But old metolachlor at Sipcam's labeled
rate does not provide growers with the reliable and effective
weed control of improved S-metolachlor. Syngenta has
more than 30 years of experience and hundreds of trials
regarding the performance of metolachlor.
"Syngenta wants to ensure that U.S. growers receive accurate
information to make decisions about their weed control program,"
said Travis Dickinson, head of business development for Syngenta
Crop Protection. "This older chemistry at Sipcam's reduced rate
simply doesn't provide the consistent, effective weed control of
Syngenta's newer products like Dual II MAGNUM® and Bicep II
MAGNUM®."
Syngenta
is a world-leading agribusiness committed to sustainable
agriculture through innovative research and technology. The
company is a leader in crop protection and ranks third in the
high-value commercial seeds market. Sales in 2002 were
approximately US $6.2 billion. Syngenta employs some 20,000
people in over 90 countries. Syngenta is listed on the Swiss
stock exchange (SYNN) and in London (SYA), New York (SYT) and
Stockholm (SYN).
Stalwart(tm)C and Stalwart(tm)Xtra are
trademarks of Sipcam Agro USA.
Bicep II MAGNUM® and Dual
II MAGNUM® are trademarks of Syngenta Group Company.
|