YaleGlobal
December 2, 2004
Asia
is home to the world's largest consumer base and the greatest
number of farmers, and thus will set the future for genetically
modified (GM) food. The GM struggle will be determined on which
side Asia takes with regards the biotechnology debate. This is
the premise of an article of John Feffer, a Pantech Fellow from
Stanford University, in
YaleGlobal, an online publication of the
Yale Center for the Study of
Globalization.
Feffer notes that “The stakes in Asia's decision on GM food are
enormous: a huge market in seeds and crops, a total
restructuring of farming practice, and a test of civil society's
strength in countries where governments routinely dictate
agricultural policy. The backlash against new technologies can
be either a temporary speed bump or a significant obstacle.”
Which side Asia accepts, Feffer adds, will determine the state
of biotechnology.
A
certain ambivalence among Asian countries suggests cautious
entry into the GM arena with strong GM research activities
tempered with moratorium on planting food crops. China for
example, has an active research and development system on GM,
remains the largest importer of GM soybeans, is growing a
significant amount of GM cotton, but has not yet approved any GM
crop for consumption.
ABSTRACT
Most media coverage of
genetically modified (GM) food has centered on disputes between
Europe and the United States. "But it is in Asia that the new
techno-food will live or die," writes John Feffer. Asia is home
to the largest consumer market, as well as the greatest number
of farmers in the world. And it must now choose between
accepting America's confidence in the safety and necessity of GM
food, or Europe's more cautious approach. Through a variety of
approaches, both the EU and the US have tried to influence
ambivalent nations to move into their camps. These efforts have
been met with resistance by farmers, consumers, and wary
governments. And mixed results in trial operations threaten
confidence in the technology. "In the end," concludes Feffer,
"Asians will determine whether the new techno-foods remake the
global diet or join radioactive fertilizer and cold fusion in
the junk bin of science."
Article:
http://yaleglobal.yale.edu/display.article?id=4956 |