Madison, Wisconsin
March 23, 2004
Roundup Ready
soybean acreage has drastically increased since their
introduction in 1996. Approximately 84% of Wisconsin soybeans
were planted to Roundup Ready in 2003 with similar trends cross
the United States. While much research had been conducted with
management of conventional soybeans, little had been conducted
to see how Roundup Ready soybeans compare.
The study of the
effect of adjusting management practices when using Roundup
Ready soybean is published in the March-April issue of Agronomy
Journal, published by the American Society of Agronomy. Authors
are Michael Bertram, University of Wisconsin-Madison and Palle
Pedersen, Iowa State University. The research was conducted
under the direction of Dr. Edward Oplinger and was supported by
the Wisconsin Soybean Marketing Board and Hatch Project 1890.
Soybeans have
traditionally been grown in wide rows, but many producers in the
northern Midwest plant in narrow rows to reduce disease severity
and to increase yield. The research was conducted to test
conventional and Roundup Ready soybean varieties from 1997 to
1999 at two locations in the southern, central, and the northern
part of Wisconsin. These varieties were grown at three row
spacings and three plant populations for each row spacing.
Conventional varieties were grown with conventional herbicides
while Roundup Ready varieties were grown with both conventional
herbicides and Roundup.
Planting soybean in
narrow (7.5 inches) or intermediate rows (15 inches) resulted in
greater yield than wide rows (30 inches). Yields were similar
with narrow rows and intermediate rows, suggesting this may be
an alternative for producers with disease concerns.
In general, soybean
yield increased when populations were raised from low to
optimum, but did not increase from optimum to high. This would
suggest that current seeding rate recommendations are adequate
and similar for both conventional and Roundup Ready soybeans.
However, Roundup Ready soybean yield was similar regardless of
plant population in northern Wisconsin.
"The results
indicate that management practices when using Roundup Ready
varieties should be similar to conventional cultivars. However,
when using Roundup Ready soybeans, it may be economically
feasible to reduce seeding rates in parts of Wisconsin, as the
results from northern Wisconsin demonstrated," says Bertram.
Online subscribers to Agronomy Journal can access the full
article; nonsubscribers can access the abstract, or pay a $10
per-article fee, or buy a $25, 14-day site pass. The article is
online at:
http://agron.scijournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/96/2/462
Agronomy Journal,
http://agron.scijournals.org
is a peer-reviewed, international journal of agriculture and
natural resource sciences published six times a year by the
American Society of Agronomy (ASA). Agronomy Journal contains
research papers on all aspects of crop and soil science
including agroclimatology and agronomic modeling, military land
use and management, environmental quality, international
agronomy, agricultural research station management, and
integrated agricultural systems.
The American Society of
Agronomy (ASA),
the Crop Science Society of
America (CSSA) and the
Soil Science Society of
America (SSSA) are educational organizations helping
their 10,000+ members advance the disciplines and practices of
agronomy, crop and soil sciences by supporting professional
growth and science policy initiatives, and by providing quality,
research-based publications and a variety of member services.
|