Forum

home   |   forum   |   news   |   job market   |   calendar   |   yellow pages   |   advertise on SeedQuest   

 
The three dominant issues: effective protection of intellectual property, development of GM crops and phytosanitary regulations
Editorial views by Dr. Bernard le Buanec is Secretary General of the International Seed Federation (ISF)

This year I attended the annual congresses of the four regional seed trade associations: AFSTA in Tunisia in March, FELAS in Paraguay in July, APSA in South Korea in September and ESA in Belgium in October. The FELAS, APSA and ESA congresses were each attended by around 500 participants from 17 (FELAS) to 37 (APSA) countries. With a smaller number of delegates (170 representing 38 countries) the AFSTA congress was also a success when one considers its ‘youth’. Together with 1269 participants from 58 countries who were in Berlin for the ISF congress, the numbers confirm the vitality of our industry and the need for regular meetings to exchange views and develop business opportunities.

Regional meetings are always enlightening as it allows me to learn about and better understand the challenges being faced by the seed industry in different parts of the world, and to put them into perspective. What are these issues that are occupying the seed industry?

Globally speaking, three issues dominate the scene: the effective protection of intellectual property, the development of GM crops and phytosanitary regulations. With respect to IP there are two main concerns viz. enforcement of existing laws to prevent the abuse of farm saved seed and the need to improve protection of parental hybrid lines. The development of GM varieties is hampered by the lack of appropriate legislations and where regulations exist their cumbersome nature, and the question of adventitious presence of GM material in non-GM crops. Few national and no international agreements on adventitious presence have been reached five years after discussion. The tendency of countries to revisit their phytosanitary laws without serious scientific reasoning has worrying consequences on the international seed trade.

In addition, the issues debated at several meetings were: implementation of the CBD and the FAO IT, establishment of national, regional and international databases of seed statistics, identity preservation and traceability, organic seed, the impact of strong national seed associations on public-private sector relationship particularly in developing countries and countries with economies in transition, and accreditation.

It is no surprise that these topics are no different from those presented by the directors/secretaries of the national associations at the occasion of their meeting during the congress in Berlin. However, an additional point raised in Berlin was that the liability facing seed companies was rising beyond what was usual for the seed trade. It is relevant here to inform members that the ISF Errors and Omissions Insurance programme established in 1999 is functioning very well. Those desirous of joining this programme should contact the ISF Secretariat.

The issues the seed industry is faced with are indeed impressive. The need for concerted action at an international level is obvious. We will certainly have to establish priorities for the coming years.

But to finish on a more upbeat note, it is satisfying to be able to close the chapter on an issue that the industry has worked hard for years to resolve. In 1994 ISF (then FIS) launched an initiative to gain accreditation for seed companies to certify and test seed. 2004 saw the culmination of this effort when the principle of accreditation of seed company employees was included in the OECD Seed Schemes and accreditation of seed company laboratories was added to ISTA’s constitution. Accredited seed companies can now inspect fields, and sample, test and certify seed under official supervision. Accredited company seed testing labs will be able to issue ISTA certificates. It is now up to national associations to pursue the actual implementation of this new rule at the national level.


This editorial is copyright © The International Seed Federation (ISF). It appears in the ISF Info newsletter Vol. XI No. 4, Oct 2004 and is reprinted here with permission from the International Seed Federation.

Dr. le Buanec can be reached at isf@worldseed.org

SeedQuest does not necessarily endorse the factual analyses and opinions
presented on this Forum, nor can it verify their validity.

Copyright © 2004 SeedQuest - All rights reserved