by Kenneth A. Albrecht, Francisco Mouriño and Daniel M.
Schaefer
Kura clover (Trifolium
ambiguum M. Bieb.) is a relatively new forage legume in
North America that has potential to be a major component of
forage-livestock industries in the north central USA. Kura
clover is native to southeastern Europe and western Asia and
grows naturally in habitats ranging from poorly drained valley
bottoms to mountain meadows at elevations greater than 10,000
feet. Although it apparently has not been domesticated in its
native region, it is a highly regarded component of grazed
natural grasslands. Introduced into the USA in 1911, commercial
development of kura clover was limited by ineffective
nodulation, seed production difficulties, and poor seedling
vigor.
Rhizobia capable of effectively nodulating kura clover have
been identified and are now available through several commercial
sources. Although seed production difficulties such as low and
inconsistent seed yields and difficult threshing still are
problems, a handful of seedsmen are now producing kura clover
seed and it is commercially available from several sources
within the USA. Seedling vigor is still a problem, but we now
have guidelines that will allow us to maximize chances for
successful establishment.
Our experience with kura clover is still quite limited, but
we have over the last several years gained some appreciation for
the adaptation, management, and productivity of this new legume.
Our knowledge about kura clover will expand and recommendations
for management of this crop will be refined over the next
several decades, but I will outline some of what we know about
it now.
Adaptation
Kura clover is widely adapted to the temperate regions of the
world and has performed especially well in the cooler temperate
regions. It is known to survive very dry conditions and is more
productive than white clover in the dry highlands of New
Zealand. In Wisconsin we have observed that kura clover tends to
go dormant sooner than alfalfa in response to drought. So,
although the plant persists through dry periods, productivity is
depressed. Stands of kura clover approaching 23 years old exist
in Minnesota and in Wisconsin 11 year old stands show no signs
of decline. Furthermore, kura clover grown on the poorly drained
soils near Marshfield, WI is in excellent condition after 6
years. Based on our observations and the literature, it seems
that kura clover soil pH and fertility requirements are similar
to red clover, i.e. it will do well under conditions that are
less than optimal for alfalfa. We conclude that kura clover is
persistent and productive in the north central states on most
agriculturally useful soils.
Characteristics
The characteristic that makes kura clover unique among the
forage legumes adapted to the north central states is its
massive rhizome (underground stem) system. The underground mass
(rhizomes and roots) of a mature stand of kura clover has been
reported to be as high as nine tons per acre. Kura cover
persistence is probably associated with the rhizome system
having large numbers of buds at various depths in the soil. When
portions of plants are damaged by cattle, machinery, or
freezing, new growth is initiated from buds on undamaged
portions of the plant.
We have found that individual kura clover plants can spread
to a diameter of three feet over a three year period if it is
not competing with other plants (Table 1). In mixtures where
there is grass competition, rhizome growth is much reduced.
Thus, unlike alfalfa, red clover, or birdsfoot trefoil, kura
clover has the ability to "fill in" open patches in a pasture or
hay field.
Table 1. Grass competition effects on spread of
individual kura clover plants by rhizomes over a three-year
period
Treatment |
Grass species |
|
Smooth bromegrass |
Kentucky bluegrass |
|
Kura clover plant diameter (in) |
Killed
grass |
321 |
33 |
Grass |
24 |
21 |
Grass +
N |
16 |
8 |
|
1Values are means over three field experiments
near Arlington and Lancaster, WI.
Kura clover is a very leafy plant with stem production
occurring primarily only in the first spring growth. During the
rest of the season leaves are produced from short stems at or
near the soil surface. Leaves are usually larger than red clover
leaves and have no hairs. Because of the high proportion of
leaves in kura clover forage, it is very high quality with
protein concentrations ranging between 18 and 25% and neutral
detergent fiber (NDF) concentrations between 25 and 40% in
Wisconsin conditions. We have found forage quality of kura
clover to be equal to or greater than other legumes and not very
sensitive to harvest management (Table 2).
Table 2. Forage quality of four legumes with two
different harvest management systems grown near Arlington, WI.
Legume |
3 harvests per year |
4 harvests per year |
|
NDF |
CP |
NDF |
CP |
|
% |
Alfalfa |
42 a1 |
21 b |
34 a |
24 |
Red
clover |
38 a |
22 ab |
32 b |
24 |
Birdsfoot trefoil |
34 b |
22 ab |
31 b |
25 |
Kura
clover |
31 b |
23 a |
30 b |
23 |
|
1
Values within a column followed by the same letter not
different at p=0.05.
Management
Kura clover has the reputation of being difficult to
establish. The above-ground portion of kura clover seedlings are
very slow to develop because much energy is used early for root
development. Rapidly growing weeds or grass in existing pastures
can be very competitive with developing kura clover seedling and
cause stand failures. We have successfully used clipping,
grazing, or herbicides for control of weeds or pasture grasses.
On an experimental basis we have found that most herbicides
compatible with red clover also work with kura clover, however
label laws must be followed carefully for commercial
applications.
Optimum seeding rates for kura clover are slightly lower than
for alfalfa. The year after establishment, forage yield of kura
clover sown at 8 or 16 lb/acre was similar at three Wisconsin
locations. We have had excellent success with 6 to 8 lb/acre of
kura clover seed when sown alone or with grasses. Grasses,
except the ryegrasses which are very competitive, can be sown at
rates recommended by the extension service for mixtures with
legumes. We have had success sowing a small amount of birdsfoot
trefoil seed (up to 50%) or red clover seed (up to 10%) with
kura clover in order to increase forage yield in the first and
second seasons. The birdsfoot trefoil or red clover dies out
after a few years and kura fills in.
As with other legumes, kura clover has the capacity to form a
symbiotic relationship with bacteria and fix substantial amounts
of atmospheric nitrogen into agriculturally useful forms. Kura
clover requires a particular strain of rhizobia (different from
red clover and alfalfa) for effective nodulation. If the seed is
not already inoculated, your seed supplier should be able to
provide the rhizobia and instructions on how to apply it. Seed
should be planted as soon after inoculation as
possible--preferably within hours. Mistakes in handling the
inoculant or inoculated seed will surely result in stand failure
because the clover will not fix nitrogen and not compete with
weeds or other forage plants. Mixtures of nodulated kura clover
with grass have yielded the same as grass fertilized with from
150 to 300 pounds of nitrogen fertilizer, depending on grass
species.
Kura clover can be grown alone or in mixtures with grass. We
have successfully grown it in mixtures with Kentucky bluegrass,
smooth bromegrass, orchardgrass and tall fescue. Thus, the grass
of choice should be the grass that a producer feels most
comfortable with. Since the quality of kura clover is so high,
it is not difficult to develop a grazing or hay harvesting
system for kura/grass mixtures that results in fiber
concentrations low enough for rations of dairy cows. Growing
grass with kura clover reduces the incidence of bloat on
pasture, brings fiber concentrations up to levels required by
ruminants and facilitates harvest and drying of hay or silage.
Persistence
Kura clover is the most persistent forage legume commercially
available for use in Wisconsin. Conditions for winter-kill of
alfalfa and red clover in 1994-95 did not affect kura clover
(Table 3). The massive rhizome and root system represents a
large underground "bud bank" for regrowth to originate from
after damage from wheel traffic, animal treading, freezing or
other. We have not observed frost heaving in kura clover and
this is also probably associated with the extensive rhizome
system. The rhizome is also a storage organ for carbohydrates
that are used as a source of energy for regrowth and after
defoliation.
Table 3. Production of four forage legumes before and
after a "test winter" in 1994-1995. Forages were grown near
Arlington, WI and harvested four times per season.
Crop |
1994 |
1995 |
1996 |
1997 |
|
tons/acre |
Alfalfa |
4.8 a |
2.5 |
2.0 b |
2.3 b |
Red
clover |
4.6 a |
2.8 |
1.7 b |
2.0 b |
Birdsfoot trefoil |
3.4 b |
3.0 |
2.3 ab |
2.3 b |
Kura
clover |
3.4 b |
2.8 |
2.9 a |
3.6 a |
|
Values within a column followed by the same letter are not
different at p=0.05.
No significant disease problems are known for kura clover,
however some insects (such as potato leafhopper) that damage
other legumes also affect kura clover. We have grown kura clover
in mixture with grasses and harvested five times per season to a
1.5 inch height for the last 11 years with no sign of decline.
Researchers in Minnesota have grazed kura clover for 12 years
and those pastures still have an excellent stand of kura clover.
Observations from long-term research in Wisconsin, Minnesota,
and other parts of the world suggest that, once established,
kura clover will be a permanent component of a pasture or
hayfield.
Productivity
The yield potential of a good stand of kura clover is usually
about 80 to 90% that of a good stand of alfalfa, based on
Wisconsin and Minnesota research (Table 3). The lower yields are
related to the large investment that the plant makes to
below-ground growth and energy storage, slow regrowth after
defoliation, and relatively early onset of dormancy in the
autumn. These characteristics that tend to limit yield are also
associated with increasing persistence. But because alfalfa, red
clover, and birdsfoot trefoil usually succumb to diseases or
winter-kill after 2 to 5 years, kura clover performance is
superior in the long term (Table 3).
Kura clover is affected little by grazing or harvest
frequency of from three to nine times per season. Since regrowth
originates from at or below the soil surface, defoliation to
ground level is not detrimental to the plant and in fact will
result in maximum yields. We have observed encroachment of
perennial weeds, especially dandelions, in monoculture kura
clover defoliated frequently and to short stubble height.
Mixtures of kura clover and grass can be managed to yield
forage of similar fiber (NDF) and crude protein (CP) levels as
early flower alfalfa (Table 4). Furthermore, excellent clover
persistence results in older stands with similar clover content
as younger stands. This is evidence that mixtures have potential
to remain stable relative to species composition and forage
quality over long periods.
Table 4. Long-term performance of ‘Rhizo’ kura clover
monoculture and mixtures with grasses near Arlington, WI. Values
presented are means over years one through three and four
through six of a long-term trial. Values are averages over three
harvest frequencies and two stubble heights.
Treatment |
Years 1-3 |
Years 4-6 |
|
Yield |
Kura |
NDF |
CP |
Yield |
Kura |
NDF |
CP |
|
T/acre1 |
--------- % ------- |
T/acre1 |
--------- % ------- |
Kentucky bluegrass/kura clover |
2.8 |
60 |
41 |
19 |
3.3 |
66 |
38 |
19 |
Smooth
bromegrass/kura clover |
2.7 |
48 |
41 |
18 |
3.1 |
63 |
37 |
19 |
Orchardgrass/kura clover |
2.6 |
44 |
44 |
19 |
2.9 |
54 |
40 |
18 |
Monoculture kura clover |
2.3 |
100 |
29 |
23 |
2.8 |
100 |
30 |
22 |
|
1
All harvests were completed by September 1 and autumn
growth is not included in these figures.
Excellent legume persistence, even when initiating grazing
early in the season (mid-April) and terminating grazing late in
the season (mid-September to late October), has resulted in
excellent animal performance on kura clover/grass pastures
(Table 5). Grasses in these pastures included a mixture of
orchardgrass, smooth bromegrass, and tall fescue in addition to
minor contributions from others. Pastures containing red
clover/grass mixtures in the trial were frost-seeded with three
to six pounds of red clover each spring to insure presence of
clover but no additional seed was added to the kura clover
pastures. Within each pasture system, cattle rotationally grazed
six paddocks, making a complete cycle in 21 to 24 days. Greater
clover proportions and productivity of the pastures containing
kura clover resulted in superior animal performance in
individual years and over the three year trial, compared to
livestock on red clover/grass pastures.
Table 5. Performance of Holstein steers on clover/grass
pastures near Lancaster, WI. Values are means over three years
(1998-2000).
Treatment |
Grazing days |
Steer days
per acre/year |
ADG
lb/day |
Gain
lb/acre/year |
3-year gain
lb/acre |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Kura
clover/grass |
169 |
345 |
2.65 |
916 |
2747 |
Red
clover/grass |
169 |
313 |
2.26 |
712 |
2137 |
|
In conclusion, persistence of kura clover is unmatched by
other legumes in the north central states. Furthermore, the very
high forage quality of kura clover provides an opportunity for
developing mixtures with grasses and obtaining mixture quality
similar to early flower alfalfa. Integration of these factors
into a pasture system has resulted in full season steer
performance at a level never before achieved in Wisconsin
pasture research trials. Kura clover is a legume that deserves
consideration for use in forage-livestock systems in the north
central states.
Endura kura clover, with the new SuperBugtm
kura-specific inoculant is now available through Ampac Seed
Company and their distributors. Ampac has also developed a
detailed web site on kura clover. For more information contact
Ampac Seed at