July 24, 1998 Choosing the variety best suited for your Mid-South farming operation
is still the number one decision in maximizing cotton profits. Yields are important but
profitability remains the most important issue. Technology considerations of Bollgard®,
Roundup Ready® and BXN® must be carefully analyzed in order to add to bottom line
profits.
Criteria that should be considered include:
Short Season Varieties.
New short-season varieties like DP 5111, DP 425 RR and DP 436 RR are ideally suited for
the Mid-South. These varieties excel in early seeding growth and vigor and handle the cool
soil planting conditions better than some mid-season varieties.
This extra growth and vigor offers dual benefits in helping push the plant through the
danger zone of the seedling disease complex, and provide producers with a more uniform
stand for over-the-top applications of Roundup Ultra on Roundup Ready varieties
and other post emergence work.
The variety trait of early season vigor in these new varieties is especially important in
no till and conservation tillage.
Roundup Ready.
The use of the Roundup Ready Systems, featured at one of the cotton stops at the Milan No
Field Day, offers reduction in weed control cost while providing seed beds free of
residual herbicide.
Pre-plant herbicides, especially during wet, cool springs, may stunt cotton in the early
stages of growth and delay maturity. Some of our plot cooperators are reporting extra
costs associated with the BXN weed control system. Some growers are having to use
pre-plant herbicides and still come back with additional over-the top applications to
clean up Buctril® escapes, especially
during this year's droughty conditions. These late applications may affect labeled
plant-back restrictions next spring.
REPLICATED IN SEASON PLANT MAPPING DATA
DELTAPINE SEED AGRONOMIC SERVICE 1997
JERRY WHITE FARM, HUNTINGTON, TENNESSEE
Variety |
Height |
Total Nodes |
Node of 1st fruiting branch |
DP 5111 |
28.5 |
15.5 |
6 |
DP 436 RR |
27.0 |
15.0 |
6 |
DP 425 RR |
28.0 |
15.0 |
6 |
STV 474 |
25.5 |
15.5 |
7.3 |
Plant Mapping.
Our plant mapping data supports early fruit initiation on widely adapted early
varieties as compared to other varieties planted in the area.
PRELIMINARY VARIETY TRIALS**
UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE
Variety |
Total lint yield |
Lint yield 1st harvest |
First harvest % |
Gin turnout % |
DP 5111 |
1,236 |
1,074 |
87.0 |
33.4 |
STV 474* |
1,127 |
923 |
81.8 |
35.8 |
SG 125* |
972 |
753 |
76.9 |
33.5 |
PM 1220* |
709 |
486 |
68.0 |
30.7 |
*Check varieties
** Data taken from preliminary variety trial data 1997 table 11 PVT-1 University of
Tennessee
Early Fruiting Advantage.
Cotton varieties that have the ability to fruit early, beginning on the 5th to 6th
node versus varieties initiating fruit on the 7th to 9th node, could have a week head
start, translating to an early harvest and higher first picking percentages. The early
first position bolls on these early starting varieties are even more important in
stressful and dry years like we are experiencing. Older, first position bolls are just
safer bolls and are less likely to shed under drought stress.
Early boll load and retention is the main factor in the cotton plant's ability to manage
plant height in aggressive growing conditions. The increased DD 60 accumulation, pushing
earlier boll load coupled with excellent retention, has been very instrumental in plant
height control and less need for PGR.
The new short season varieties are ideally suited for once-over picking, reducing harvest
cost. High retention of first position bolls has a major impact on boll maturation. The
traditional 55 to 65 days may be shortened when over 50 percent of the plant bolls are on
1st position.
Dr. Owen Gwathmey, Department of Plant and Soil Science of the University of Tennessee
Agricultural Experiment Station of Jackson, Tennessee, in his 1997 Preliminary Cotton
Test, reports the earliness of several varieties in conjunction with yield and percent
open on the first picking.
Bollgard Varieties Influence Earliness:
Dr. Gary L. Lentz, Associate Professor, University of Tennessee's Department of
Entomology and Plant Science in his 1997 Comparison of Yield and Maturity Test, reports
higher yields and significantly more cotton at first harvest with new Bollgard varieties.
This comparison was made with DP 20 B and DP 50 B compared with their recurrent parents.
DP 20 B produced the highest yields of 1,040 lbs. lint with 75.8 percent at first harvest.
Worm control at below economic thresholds may be a factor in the increased yields. These
new short season cotton varieties continue to demonstrate in cotton fields their earliness
in 1998 with early fruit initiation and boll load.
Comparison of Yield and Maturity of Four Deltapine Cotton Varieties
Lint Yield (lb.)
Variety |
First |
Second |
Total |
1st harvest |
Deltapine 20 |
484c |
174b |
658d |
73.9 |
Deltapine 50 |
657b |
192b |
849c |
77.2 |
DP 20 B |
787a |
253a |
1040a |
75.8 |
DP 50 B |
734a |
203b |
937b |
78.6 |
P>F |
0.0001 |
0.004 |
0.0001 |
0.063 |
By Jim Presley
Deltapine Seed Midsouth Regional Agronomic Service Manager
Bollgard®, Roundup Ready® and Roundup Ultra are
trademarks of Monsanto.
BXN® is a registered trademark of Stoneville Pedigreed Seed.
Buctril® is a registered trademark of RhonePoulenc.
N1519 |