Fargo, North Dakota
September 4, 2008
There has been a great deal of
discussion on the potential role of switchgrass as a dedicated
feedstock for cellulosic-based biofuels. Along with studies
aimed at growing a better plant, researchers in the
North Dakota State
University Department of Agribusiness and Applied Economics
have evaluated switchgrass from an economic point of view.
Switchgrass is a warm-season perennial grass that is native to
North Dakota and the region.
"We looked at switchgrass from two perspectives," says F. Larry
Leistritz, NDSU economist. "We studied farm-gate prices that
would be needed for switchgrass to be competitive with net
returns from traditional crops based on different levels of soil
productivity. We also studied farm-gate prices that would be
needed for switchgrass to be competitive with net returns from
traditional crops based on different levels of producer
profitability."
Breakeven switchgrass prices were estimated as the price
required to cover switchgrass production expenses and provide
for the same level of net return from traditional crops.
Three types of soils were used: marginal, average and high
productivity. To break even with traditional crops, producers
would need to receive $47 per ton from low-productivity soil,
$67 per ton from average soil and $76 per ton from the most
productive soil.
"Several variables, such as yield increases, fertilizer costs,
changes in traditional crop prices and crop rotations, may
influence the willingness of a producer to grow switchgrass,"
Leistritz says. "However, what is important is that we now
better understand the factors that will influence the economic
competiveness of herbaceous crops, such as switchgrass, with the
more traditional crops. It also is important that energy
industry leaders, policymakers and researchers now have
additional information with which to continue evaluating the
economic viability of cellulosic ethanol."
Others involved in the study from the NDSU Department of
Agribusiness and Applied Economics were Dan Bangsund and Eric
DeVuyst. |
|