The
Philippines
October 10, 2006
By
Sosimo Ma. Pablico, Ph.D., Agriculture Magazine August 2006 via SEAMEO SEARCA
The Philippines may as well also consider sweet sorghum as
sustainable source of ethanol, as it can now use the knowledge
and science developed in India as a solid basis for full-scale
commercialization. Ethanol can be blended with petrol to reduce
dependence on fossil fuels, and minimize carbon and monoxide
emission in motor vehicles.
Ethanol is a "clean burning fuel" with high octane rating. Thus,
there are claims that existing automobile engines can be
operated with petrol blended with ethanol without any need for
engine modification.
At present, the country imports $3.9 billion worth of crude oil
and petroleum products a year.
Dr.
William D. Dar, the Filipino director general of the
International Center for
Research in the Semi-Arid Tropics [ICRISAT] in India, said
that since the biofuels initiative in the country today is very
important for our survival, "we should be looking for the
variety of major sources of bio-fuels that we can develop and
sustain," Dar said in an email to this writer.
"We need to promote commercialize sweet sorghum for ethanol
production," he said, as sweet sorghum offers the best
alternative source of raw material.
The production of ethanol from sweet sorghum will not only save
enormous amount of foreign exchange but also reduce pollution
and provide cleaner air for a constantly growing population.
In a paper sent to this writer, Dar said sweet sorghum is best
suited for ethanol production because of its higher sugar
content compared to other sources like sugarcane and Jatropha.
In addition, unlike sugarcane, sweet sorghum is propagated
through the use of seeds and suitable for mechanized crop
production. Likewise, there is practically no wastage in sweet
sorghum since every part is used starting from sugar extraction,
fuel for boilers and animal feed.
Besides the stalks for ethanol production, sweet sorghum
varieties produce grain yields of 2 to 2.5 t/ha, which can be
used as food/feed or for potable alcohol preparation. Compared
with sugarcane whose sugar content is only 10 to 20 percent,
that of sweet sorghum is 15 to 23 percent.
Further, silage from sweet sorghum has higher biological value
than bagasse from sugarcane when used as feed for animals, as it
is rich in micronutrients and minerals.
Aside from its multiple uses as food, feed, forage and source of
ethanol, sorghum seeds can be harvested in 100 days. Moreover,
its ratoon also matures in 85 to 95 days after cutting. In
contrast, it takes almost a year for a sugarcane crop to mature.
Furthermore, it is cheaper to produce sweet sorghum than
sugarcane. In India, for instance, the cost of cultivating sweet
sorghum is about one-third that of sugarcane.
At the Mariano Marcos State University, which is headed by Dr.
Miriam E. Pascua, five sweet sorghum varieties developed at
ICRISAT have been found to mature in 100 days, according to Dr.
Heraldo L. Layaoen, MMSU vice president for administration who
is also the coordinator of an MMSU-ICRISAT sorghum project.
Seeds of sweet sorghum varieties NTJ 2, SPV 422, ICSV 700, ICSV
93046 and ICSR 93034 are now available at MMSU. Results of the
production trials showed that their grain yields in the seed
crop ranged from 3.28 to 3.62 t/ha, while that in the first
ratoon varied from 3.92 to 4.40 t/ha.
Similarly, the stalk yields of these varieties in the seed crop
ranged from 43.48 to 55.60 t/ha, while the first ratoon produced
45.5 to 57.65 t/ha. Although variety SPV 422 consistently
produced the lowest grain yield, it also consistently produced
the highest stalk yield and the highest sugar content [19
percent]. Please see accompanying table.
Variety |
Stripped Stalk Yield
(t/ha) |
Grain Yield (t/ha) |
Percent Sugar |
Seed Crop |
First Ratoon |
Seed Crop |
First Ratoon |
NTJ 2 |
45.50 |
48.55 |
3.62 |
4.40 |
18.5 |
SPV 422 |
55.60 |
57.65 |
3.28 |
3.92 |
19.0 |
ICSV 700 |
43.48 |
45.50 |
3.46 |
4.11 |
18.0 |
ICSV 93046 |
47.52 |
48.55 |
3.40 |
4.08 |
15.0 |
ICSR 93034 |
46.52 |
47.53 |
3.46 |
4.25 |
18.0 |
Already, the provinces of Isabela, Apayao, Ilocos Sur have
already signified their interest in planting sweet sorghum,
Layaoen said. In Ilocos Norte, however, only Batac and Banna
have shown interest in the new technology.
"Considering the early maturity, higher biomass potential and
less photoperiod sensitivity of hybrids compared to varieties,
it is desirable to promote the cultivation and use of sweet
sorghum hybrids for ethanol production," Dar said.
According to Dar, a techno-economic feasibility study undertaken
by National Research for Council for Sorghum [NCRS] in
Hyderabad, India with the collaboration of a private distillery
revealed that the cost of producing ethanol per liter from sweet
sorghum is slightly lower than that from sugarcane molasses.
For its part, ICRISAT has developed excellent sweet sorghum
varieties and hybrids for use in ethanol production by the sugar
industries/alcohol distilleries.
With the collaboration of the NCRS and state agricultural
universities in India, ICRISAT is engaged in sweet sorghum
improvement research for ethanol production along with other
types of sorghum to broaden marketing opportunities to improve
the livelihoods of poor farmers.
One area in which they are focused is photoperiod sensitivity.
"Photoperiod insensitivity (as in hybrids) is useful to
facilitate planting at different dates to ensure a regular
supply of sweet sorghum stalks in required quantities to
distilleries for ethanol production," Dar said.
He stressed that ethanol production form sweet sorghum is a good
business enterprise that must involve the small farmers, which
is what they are doing now in India.
"This is the model we are working on at ICRISAT and we have the
first distillery in the world on ethanol production using sweet
sorghum invested in by the private sector. We have been
incubating this idea and this distillery stated its operation
this June, " Dar revealed.
No less than 6,000 hectares planted to sweet sorghum by
smallholders supply the raw materials for distillery.
On the other hand, Dar also warned that the knowledge based on
Jatropha as ethanol source must be built up first and its
science and technology support must be put up prior to its
massive commercialization. He said that in India where the use
of Jatropha as ethanol source is considered advance, the Indian
Council for Agricultural Research has approved only one variety
of this crop for release and commercialization.
He said, however, "we should now enhance the approval of the
Biofuels Act to consider a variety of sources of biofuel, not
only Jatropha."
At the same time, a blueprint for biofuels development and
commercialization must be put with private sector and public
institutions working together, Dar stressed. "This roadmap must
always include science and technology support, capacity
building, infrastructure development, mobilization of
investments and other important matters."
This blueprint must be knowledge-based and equally involve big
business and the small farmers.
"Let's do it well and systematically this time," he added. |