Fargo, North Dakota
July 27, 2006
North Dakota State
University's Research Plot No. 2 is possibly the only
agricultural research plot in the world to have been
continuously planted to wheat. Located on the NDSU campus, it
was planted to wheat 125 years ago.
In 1991, Research Plot No. 2, along with NDSU's Flax Plot No.
30, was entered into the National Register of Historic Places.
In 1999, David Weller, research plant pathologist with the
USDA's Agricultural Research Service at the Root Disease and
Biological Control Research Unit in Pullman, Wash., said,
"Basically, the NDSU Wheat Plot No. 2 is a national treasure."
For scientists interested in soil fertility, crop rotation and
naturally occurring organisms that control plant diseases, Plot
No. 2 is a valuable resource. Prior to being sown to wheat, the
plot had been tallgrass prairie. After 10 years of continuous
cropping to wheat, the poor crop yields that were experienced
were believed to be due to poor soil fertility or "wheat-sick"
soil, as it was termed then.
W.M. Hays, NDSU agriculturalist, set up a series of 29 one-acre
plots in 1892. Hays used crop rotation to assess performance,
but kept Plot No. 1 and Plot No. 2 as control plots. After
experimentation, H.L. Bolley, NDSU's first plant pathologist,
proved that this "wheat-sick" soil that was causing decreased
yields actually was due to a buildup of plant pathogens
(disease), not poor fertility. Bolley made recommendations in
1909 regarding crop rotation, seed treatments and wheat diseases
that still are practiced today.
"There is a general belief that the reason natural ecosystems
have less disease epidemics than monoculture systems is because
the greater diversity acts as a buffer, so not all plants in the
mixture will be susceptible to the disease," says Stephen Neate,
NDSU plant pathologist and associate professor. "This plot has
demonstrated that a monoculture can work."
Neate says microbes in the soil are part of a large, balanced
food web where some microbes eat or decay the plot material,
with the bigger microbes and soil animals eating the smaller
ones.
"The pathogens are part of this balanced food web," Neate says.
"It seems that in the early days of planting continuous wheat,
the web was out of balance and the pathogens were able to
dominate. Now, after many years of monoculture, these soils have
returned to a balanced food web. What is scientifically
important about Plot No. 2 is that testing has shown that this
soil, as with some other soils around the world that are
continuously planted to the same crop, has developed soil
microbes that produce a chemical that biologically suppresses
"take-all," a serious root disease in cereal crops. These types
of situations give us an unparalleled opportunity to study the
soil ecosystem and likely will give us information on how to
sustainably manage our agricultural soils."
Marcia McMullen, NDSU Extension Service plant pathologist, says
the plot is a valuable source of biological information and an
important site for screening against root diseases.
In the late 1800s, wheat was the No. 1 crop in North Dakota. An
entry by Hays in the May 1893 North Dakota Agricultural
Experiment Station Bulletin says, "Wheat should continue as our
main and most profitable crop. What country can better raise
wheat or with what commodity can we better compete in the
markets of the world?"
Wheat continues to be North Dakota's No. 1 agricultural
commodity, producing 21.4 percent of the state's total cash
receipts. North Dakota is the top producer of spring wheat in
the U.S. |