Columbus, Ohio
April 20, 2006
When it comes to managing weeds
with herbicides, the worst thing a grower can do is encourage
herbicide resistance through overuse or improper management.
Years of mismanaging glyphosate in Ohio crop fields have
resulted in widespread herbicide resistance of horseweed
(marestail) and a few cases of resistance of some problematic
weeds such as common lambsquarters and giant ragweed. However,
initiating proper glyphosate management now can help reduce
further damage, said Jeff Stachler, an
Ohio State University Extension
weed specialist.
"Glyphosate controls nearly all weeds. That's why it is such a
great product," said Stachler, who also holds a research
appointment with the Ohio Agricultural Research and Development
Center. "But because of its effectiveness, growers are overusing
glyphosate, which is actually having a detrimental effect on
controlling weeds. Our expectations of glyphosate are too high
and we should no longer count on glyphosate to consistently
control weeds that are too large, greater than 12 inches."
Reducing the frequency of glyphosate applications is the most
simple and effective approach to reducing glyphosate-resistant
weeds, but it may not always be practical for growers based on
their field situations. As an alternative, one approach growers
can take is properly managing glyphosate, said Stachler.
"If you don't properly manage glyphosate, you are at a greater
risk for poorer weed control, which can result in lower yields,
and you are at a greater risk for increased pressure of
glyphosate-resistant weeds," he said. "Proper glyphosate
management will not solve the problems associated with
glyphosate overuse, but it will greatly improve its negative
impacts."
Improper management practices with glyphosate that growers tend
to fall victim to are: not using the correct rate, applying at
the wrong weed size and weed age, applying during the wrong time
of the day, using improper boom height, not maximizing rain
fastness after an application, not choosing the best additives,
paying little attention to environmental conditions and applying
during dusty conditions.
Stachler offers the following recommendations to growers when
using glyphosate:
Use the correct rate. For most weed species, the traditional use
rate is 0.75 pounds of acid equivalent per acre (lbs ae/A).
However, research has shown that to more consistently control
such species as giant ragweed, common lambsquarters, velvetleaf,
common pokeweed, marestail, morningglory, and perennial
nightshade species requires a minimum rate of 1.1-1.5 lb ae/A.
Apply at the right weed size. Annual weed species should be less
than six inches tall for the best control with the exception of
giant ragweed, which may be up to 10 inches tall. For
perennials, however, plants should be sprayed when they are
larger. "You want perennials in the bud-to-early flowering stage
of development for maximum control during the growing season,"
said Stachler. Most Ohio fields have a mix of different species,
so it is very difficult to correctly apply glyphosate for all
species with a single application. The use of a pre-emergence
herbicide can allow for a more timely glyphosate application for
a broader spectrum of weeds.
Apply at the right weed age for annual species. A younger plant
can be controlled more effectively than an older plant. Growers
should not allow annual weeds to get much older than 21-30 days.
Consider making a second glyphosate application. "A second
application can and usually does improve control of weed species
even if the first application was not completely effective,"
said Stachler. "However, use this only as a short-term strategy.
With numerous applications, weed populations will change by
developing glyphosate resistance." A second application of
glyphosate is most effective when using the correct rate during
the first application.
Apply at the right time of day. The best time to apply
glyphosate is between 9 a.m. and 6 p.m. for certain species.
Nutrient movement in plants is at its maximum during the middle
of a sunny day. Hence, glyphosate movement will also be
increased. Studies have shown that the worst time of the day to
apply glyphosate is between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m. for species such
as giant ragweed and velvetleaf.
Maximize rain fastness. Rain fastness is the rain-free period
required after application to obtain maximum control. "The rain
fastness for some glyphosate products is only 30 minutes. But 30
minutes is not enough time to effectively control species such
as common lambsquarters," said Stachler. "The longer the
rain-free period, the greater the effectiveness."
Be mindful of additives and tank-mix partners. Control can be
reduced for some weed species when adding certain drift-control
agents when also using a drift-reducing nozzle. "You create a
large droplet with the nozzle and even a larger droplet with the
drift-reducing agent," said Stachler. "Because of the increased
volume and the heavier weight, a droplet may miss the target and
hit the soil." Adding a high quality nonionic surfactant can
improve control, but Stachler noted the technique would not be
as beneficial as increasing the glyphosate rate. Not all
glyphosate formulations are the same. The largest difference in
products is the amount and type of surfactant that is added. The
addition of manganese fertilizers usually decreases glyphosate
activity. The EDTA form of manganese causes the fewest weed
control problems when mixed with glyphosate. Clay-based
herbicides such as atrazine and Sencor can tie up glyphosate and
make it less effective. Other he! rbicides, especially contact
herbicides, can also decrease glyphosate activity.
Always add the correct amount of ammonium sulfate (AMS) with
glyphosate mixtures. When applying glyphosate only, the minimum
rate of AMS, 8.5 pounds per 100 gallons of spray mixture
(lbs/100 gallons), can be effective during ideal growing
conditions. The maximum use rate of AMS, 17 lb/100 gallons,
should always be used when mixing a manganese fertilizer with
glyphosate during less than ideal growing conditions, when
tank-mixing with antagonistic herbicides, and when using hard
water. The biggest reason for adding AMS to glyphosate mixtures
is to reduce cations from attaching to the glyphosate molecule.
When large cations attach to the glyphosate molecule, weed
control is almost always reduced.
Check the boom height. Weed size and boom height go
hand-in-hand, said Stachler. Spraying smaller weeds means more
uniform plant height and an easier time to adjust the boom than
spraying when weeds are much larger. "Many growers lower the
boom height to reduce drift. With larger weeds, they tend to
over compensate, which results in poorer herbicide coverage,"
said Stachler. "With smaller weeds, it's easier to achieve
proper boom height." Since perennial weed species are best
controlled with glyphosate when they are larger, carefully
adjust boom height. The minimum distance from the nozzle on the
boom to the tallest weed in the field should always be 15
inches, but may need to be higher depending upon nozzle angle
and spacing.
Be more aware of environmental conditions. Growers should pay
closer attention to environmental conditions that could stress
the weed and make it more difficult to control. Factors such as
moisture, temperature, humidity, wind speed, pests, and soil
nutrient levels all play a role in the overall health of a
plant.
Spray in low-dust conditions. Clay particles and organic matter
are negatively charged, while glyphosate molecules are
positively charged. When the two come into contact with each
other, the glyphosate is rendered ineffective. "Using a higher
rate can reduce the problem, but not always," said Stachler. |