Winnipeg,
Manitoba
November 1, 2005
The rights and livelihood of western Canadian farmers are being
threatened in the trade battle between the European Union and
the United States, as the two superpowers push for a new
agreement at the World Trade Organization (WTO).
As part of a new offer released
last Friday, the EU has insisted on elimination of the CWB's
single-desk marketing system, set up to empower western Canadian
farmers to compete against large multinational grain companies
and leverage premiums from the international marketplace.
"Our single-desk system is not
trade distorting, so it has no place on the table at the WTO,"
said CWB trade committee chair Larry Hill, a farmer from Swift
Current. "The Europeans have absolutely no grounds for demanding
its elimination, " he added, pointing to recent rulings by a WTO
dispute-settlement panel, a NAFTA panel and the U.S.
International Trade Commission, which all upheld the
Canadian Wheat Board (CWB) as a
fair trader and dismissed unfounded American allegations.
"This is clearly an attempt to
pacify the U.S. without giving up much in terms of Europe's own
hugely-distorting farm subsidies. Prairie farmers are caught in
the crossfire."
Pressure on the CWB's
single-desk marketing system at the WTO originates with the
U.S., where political pressure from special interest groups --
particularly North Dakota -- has led the American government to
launch a multi-pronged attack on the CWB.
Hill said it was crucial that
WTO members understand Canada has already made significant
concessions in the talks that will affect the CWB – including
the elimination of its financial guarantees if a WTO agreement
is ultimately reached. He said the worst offenders
(overwhelmingly the EU and U.S.) should make the biggest
concessions.
Yet last Friday's proposal from
the EU still fails to make meaningful cuts to its own
trade-distorting farm subsidies. Its offer to cut maximum
allowable support levels by 70 per cent will not affect its
actual spending on trade-distorting domestic support.
"We still have a situation
where the big offenders have not put meaningful concessions on
the table," Hill said. "Yet they point fingers at other nations
and at programs that are not even part of the overall problem."
An American offer, released
earlier this month, also failed to make cuts that would have any
major impact on its trade-distorting domestic farm supports.
Hill said Prairie farmers could
end up having the Americans and Europeans (their major grain
competitors) dictate what sort of marketing system is allowed in
Canada. He called on farmers to let the Canadian government know
that a good deal should not come at the expense of their
marketing advantage.
Controlled by western Canadian
farmers, the CWB is the largest wheat and barley marketer in the
world. As one of Canada's biggest exporters, the Winnipeg-based
organization sells to over 70 countries and returns all sales
revenue, less marketing costs, to Prairie farmers. |