West Lafayette, Indiana
May 4, 2005Cantaloupe
growers who walk their fields searching for two crop-damaging
insects can do just as good a job if they let the pests come to
them.
A three-year study by
Purdue University Extension
entomologist Frankie Lam found that striped and spotted cucumber
beetles captured with yellow sticky traps provided as accurate a
pest count as traditional hand sampling. Lam's research also
discovered that beetle activity is highest around midday.
The findings could lead to more
timely and efficient insecticide applications for Hoosier
cantaloupe growers.
Indiana ranks fifth among the
states in cantaloupe production. Hoosier growers produced 50
million pounds of muskmelons in 2004, at a market value of
nearly $10 million. Indiana's cantaloupe season runs from about
late April to mid-July, to meet peak demand around Independence
Day.
The striped and spotted
cucumber beetles, so named for the distinctive markings on their
backs, are a danger to cantaloupe plants because the insects
carry bacterial wilt disease. Once infected with wilt,
cantaloupe plants die.
"Most growers sample cucumber
beetles directly on the plants," Lam said. "It is difficult,
time-consuming and labor-intensive."
Lam, who conducts research at
Southwest-Purdue Agricultural Center near Vincennes, Ind.,
wondered whether yellow sticky traps might offer an alternative
to hand sampling. The traps, which work along the same principle
as flypaper, attract insects drawn to the bright yellow
rectangles.
Lam placed traps randomly in
research plots. Traps were positioned vertically just above the
cantaloupe plants and horizontally at plant canopy level.
"I then counted the beetles
every two hours, from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. on the following day
after the traps were placed in the field," Lam said. "Each time
I counted 10 plants on one replication. I sampled five times in
a day and looked for the correlation between the beetles on the
plants and the beetles on the traps.
"I found that if you have 20
beetles on a sticky trap within 48 hours then you've reached the
threshold of one beetle per plant on the muskmelon."
An average of one beetle per
plant is a level sufficient for growers to consider applying
insecticide, Lam said.
Lam's research also found that
cucumber beetles are most active in the early afternoon. The
insects apparently prefer warmer temperatures, he said.
"The beetles are most active at
noon in the summer," Lam said. "For insects, different species
may prefer different temperatures. I believe the cucumber beetle
prefers a warmer temperature but not a hot temperature. Early in
the morning the temperature may be too cold and the beetle may
need to warm up before becoming active. Then after about 2 p.m.
the temperature is hot and the insect is not so active. If
growers want to sample for beetles, I recommend the best time to
go out is roughly 11 a.m. to 3 p.m."
Sampling should be done two to
three times per week in the first month of the growing season
and once or twice per week after that until harvest, Lam said.
"The striped cucumber beetle
has two generations during the crop season in Indiana but
because harvest is tied to the Fourth of July, we're mainly
concerned about the first population on cantaloupes," Lam said.
Sticky trap sampling should not
add to cantaloupe growers' production costs, Lam said.
"The cost of direct sampling
and using sticky traps may be similar," he said. "If you direct
sample beetles you'll have to hire people to count the insects.
With sticky traps you don't need to do that. You only need to
buy and set up the traps, wait for a few hours and then look at
them and see how many insects you've got.
"Moneywise, it's more or less
the same for both methods. But the sticky trap method may be
easier than direct count."
More information on sticky trap
sampling and cucumber beetle control is available in a pair of
articles written by Lam for Purdue's Vegetable Crops Hotline
newsletter. The newsletter is available online at
http://www.entm.purdue.edu/entomology/ext/targets/newslett.htm
. "Using Sticky Traps to Sample Cucumber Beetles on Muskmelon"
appeared in the newsletter's March 18 issue, while "An
Integrated Pest Management Program for Cucumber Beetles on
Muskmelons" appeared in the April 8 issue. |