April 15, 2004
Conventional and real-time
PCR-based assay for detecting pathogenic Alternaria brassicae
in cruciferous seed. Thomas Guillemette, UMR 77
Pathologie Végétale, Faculté des Sciences, Angers, France;
Béatrice Iacomi-Vasilescu, UMR 77 Pathologie Végétale, France,
and USAMV, Department of Plant Protection, Bucharest, Romania;
and Philippe Simoneau, UMR 77 Pathologie Végétale, France. Plant
Dis. D-2004-0301-01R, 2004 (online). Accepted for publication 19
December 2003.
Alternaria brassicae is an important and widely
distributed pathogen of crucifers. This fungus is responsible
for the black spot disease that results in serious reductions in
crop yields. Genetic control of the pathogen is not possible
because most commercial cultivars are susceptible. Consequently,
the use of pathogen-free seed is essential to limit the spread
and incidence of the disease and also to reduce fungicide
applications. Therefore, sanitary certification programs for
commercial cruciferous seed include A. brassicae
detection. Diagnosis currently is obtained after plating seed on
nutritive media, using incubation and morphological
characterization of the fungus. This procedure is
time-consuming—requiring at least 1 week to obtain a diagnostic
result—and often not very accurate due to potential confusion
with nonpathogenic Alternaria spp. Therefore, there is
an urgent need to develop alternative diagnostic tools such as
molecular techniques based on polymerase chain reaction (PCR).
In this article, we describe two molecular assays for detecting
A. brassicae in cruciferous seed using conventional or
real-time PCR. The two methods perform equally well in terms of
specificity, sensitivity, and speed. However, the real-time PCR
assay is better suited for routine detection because no
post-amplification manipulations are required. Furthermore,
this real-time PCR diagnosis method may be readily amenable to
automation.
The current issue of
APSNet, Volume 88, Number 5,
May 2004, is at
http://www.apsnet.org/pd/current/top.asp |