Yesterday, Monsanto Company
(NYSE: MON - News) won a key patent dispute over Bayer
CropScience regarding herbicide-tolerant corn. The unanimous
decision of the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences for
the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office upheld the patent rights and priority of Monsanto's
DEKALB Genetics subsidiary for glufosinate-tolerant corn, and
rejected claims for patentability of the same technology by
Bayer's affiliate Plant Genetics Systems NV (PGS).
"We're delighted that this dispute finally has been resolved
in Monsanto's favor," said Robert T. Fraley, Ph.D., executive
vice president and chief technology officer for Monsanto. "We're
pleased for the team of devoted scientists at DEKALB who were
intimately involved in the innovations that created the first
glufosinate-tolerant corn, including the issuance of the '318
patent, and the subsequent commercial herbicide-tolerant corn
products that have been marketed by other seed corn companies
since the mid-1990s."
Glufosinate is a herbicide manufactured and sold by Bayer
under the trade name Liberty. Crops containing tolerance to this
herbicide are referred to as "Liberty Link" crops. Based on
industry estimates, roughly 1.2 million U.S. acres were planted
to Liberty Link corn in 2002. Another 3.4 million acres in the
United States used glufosinate resistance as a selectable marker
for certain insect-protected corn events during 2002, such as
Herculex and BT11, which are licensed under prior agreements
negotiated with Monsanto.
"Beneficial products developed using our patented technology
are important to farmers and other companies engaged in the
improvement of corn, and Monsanto has a well-established track
record of broadly licensing our technologies to corn seed
companies," Fraley said.
The patent interference issue was originally declared on July
9, 1997, and involves U.S. Patent No. 5,550,318 assigned to
DEKALB and an application assigned to PGS, whose successor in
interest is Bayer.