Bassersdorf, Switzerland
August 19, 2005
At the last Ordinary Meeting of
the International Seed Testing
Association (ISTA), voting delegates representing 34
national governments supported the inclusion of Rules for the
testing of specified traits (including the detection,
identification and quantification of Genetically Modified Seed)
into Chapter 8 of the ISTA International Rules for Seed Testing.
In difference to other seed tests, no standard method will be
described in the ISTA International Rules for Seed Testing, but
the testing for specified traits (including the detection,
identification and quantification of Genetically Modified Seed)
will be done under a performance based approach.
Under the performance based approach, the laboratory can freely
choose a method, however has to fulfil three conditions before
accreditation:
- provide performance data
on the successful implementation of the method in the
laboratory as prescribed in the relevant ISTA documents,
with a special focus on the parameters accuracy and
repeatability.
- successfully participate
in the ISTA Proficiency Test,
- successfully participate
in the ISTA Audit Programme.
Not to include a standard method
into the ISTA International Rules for Seed Testing is new for
ISTA. Quite a number of intensive discussions, also with ISTA's
international and regional partners, the International Seed
Federation (ISF), International Society of Seed Technologists
(ISST) and the Association of Official Seed Analysts (AOSA),
have taken place regarding the right approach to move forward.
At the end, the conclusion was that methods to perform
bio-molecular tests and bioassays require highly sophisticated
equipment, skilled operators and specialized laboratory
equipment and more than this, these methods are currently under
a rapid development and improvement and may require specific
laboratory optimising and updating.
Therefore, ISTA is convinced that
over a time range of three to five years, a performance based
approach is more favourable to achieve reliable and reproducible
test results in the area of the testing of specified traits than
working on the establishment of a standard methods.
With the positive vote of the Governments in ISTA to include the
performance based approach in the ISTA Rules, ISTA will start
with the accreditation of laboratories on the detection of
specified traits in seed lots on February 2006.
The aim will be to provide
reliable and reproducible testing results on international level
through the ISTA accredited laboratories.
We feel that this is a tremendous step forward and will create
the necessary confidence in the testing results for the
Governments to fulfil their monitoring tasks and for the seed
trade to market their seed on international level without
greater financial risks.
The relevant ISTA accreditation documents can be downloaded free
of charge from the ISTA Website
https://www.seedtest.org/stream/nl-l---1--%400dfbc7321031--27.html
1. Principles and Conditions for Laboratory Accreditation under
the Performance Based approach.
2. Performance Data Evaluation for the presence of seed with
specified trait(s) in seed lots
3. The ISTA Accreditation Standard |